Storyteller Podcast
Love true crime, mysteries, folklore, and all things strange? So do we. Each week, one host dives deep into a wild, spooky, or unbelievable story—from history’s forgotten scandals and eerie folktales to chilling true crime, bizarre conspiracies, and unexplained hauntings.
The twist? Her best friend and co-host has no idea what the story is about until the mic is on. You’ll hear her genuine reactions—shock, laughter, and “wait, WHAT?!” moments—as the mystery unfolds in real time.
It’s storytime meets late-night sleepover vibes: equal parts creepy, fascinating, and fun.
If you’re into dark history, unsolved mysteries, and the kind of stories you can’t wait to tell your friends about, hit play—you’re in for a ride.
Episodes
30 episodes
Brad Cunningham is a Murdering D-Bag (Part One)
In this chilling true crime podcast episode, we uncover the disturbing story of Bradley Morris Cunningham—a charming, wealthy manipulator whose pattern of abuse left a trail of broken women… and ultimately, murder. Before the...
•
Episode 30
•
58:03
Ona Judge- George Washington's Slave...Who Got Away
In this gripping episode of Storyteller, we uncover the incredible true story of Ona Judge, the enslaved woman who made a daring escape from none other than George Washington and his household in 1796.Born into slavery at Mount Vernon, O...
•
Episode 29
•
51:30
.png)
Diane Downs- Part 3
The investigation reaches its breaking point in Part Three of our Diane Downs series.After a shocking roadside shooting leaves three children gravely wounded, investigators begin to question whether the story told that night is th...
•
Episode 28
•
1:07:41
.png)
Diane Downs- Part 2
In Part Two of our three-part true crime series on Diane Downs, the story takes a darker and more obsessive turn.After the events of Part One, Diane’s life begins to spiral around a single obsession — a coworker named Nick Knic...
•
Episode 27
•
58:33
.png)
Diane Downs- Part 1
A mother rushes into an emergency room screaming that someone has shot her children.But long before that night, there was another story — one shaped by control, rebellion, longing, and a lifelong search for love.In Part One of our...
•
Episode 26
•
41:49
.png)
Butte's Dimple Knees Sex Scandal
Butte, Montana. The Berkeley Pit. The Copper Kings. And beneath it all — a city fueled by brothels, bribes, and backroom deals.In the 1960s, madam Beverly Snodgrass ran two of Butte’s most notorious houses of prostitution — until her aff...
•
Episode 25
•
1:18:32
A Valentine for His Mistress- The Valentines Day Murder of Denise Leuthold
💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔On Valentine’s Day 2013, Denise Leuthold spent the morning the way she always did — making a special holiday breakfast for her children, exchanging cards with her husband, and heading into an ordinary afternoon.Hours late...
•
Episode 24
•
1:04:34
Brett Favre and the Mississippi Swindle
What happens when an NFL legend decides the rules don't apply to him? 🏈In this episode, we go beyond the 299 consecutive games and the three MVP awards to uncover the dark side of Brett Favre's legacy. Is this a story of blin...
•
Episode 23
•
55:35
The Serial Killer They Let Go | Arthur Shawcross- The Genesee River Serial Killer
🚨Trigger Warning/Disclaimer🚨This episode discusses real events involving extreme violence, sexual assault, and crimes against children. Some material may be deeply disturbing. This story is told to examine systemic failures and honor the...
•
Episode 22
•
1:22:45
Little Miss Unsinkable: Violet Jessop- Surviving the Olympic, Titanic, and Britannic
What are the odds of surviving the three greatest maritime disasters of the 20th century? Meet Violet Constance Jessop, the woman history calls "Miss Unsinkable."In this episode, we explore the incredible life of a woman who was the "con...
•
Episode 21
•
49:05
The Bitter Blood Murders- Part 4
In the final episode of Bitter Blood, the violence that has been building beneath the surface finally erupts — leaving devastation in its wake.Part 4 examines the murders that shocked the South, the investigation that unraveled ...
•
Episode 20
•
1:07:18
The Bitter Blood Murders- Part 3
In Part 3 of Bitter Blood, the lines between belief and behavior begin to disappear.This episode explores the marriage between Susie Sharp and Fritz Klenner — and how two deeply ingrained worldviews fused into something far more...
•
Episode 19
•
44:58
The Bitter Blood Murders- Part 2
In Part 2 of Bitter Blood, we step away from the first murders and travel backward — into the history of a powerful Southern family whose legacy would help shape one of the most disturbing true crime cases in American history.Th...
•
Episode 18
•
58:36
The Bitter Blood Murders- Part 1
Ready for a story that reads like a Southern Gothic crime drama...that is completely real?Welcome to Part 1 of our multi part series where we are digging deep into a real-life murder case involving interconnected, promine...
•
Episode 17
•
30:34
Alice Roosevelt- The White House Wild Child
In this episode of Storyteller, we unravel the incredible life of Alice Roosevelt, daughter of President Theodore Roosevelt and one of the most fascinating women of the early 20th century. If you love stories of powerful wo...
•
Episode 16
•
44:00
Yuletide Nightmares: 12 Creepy Legends of Spookmas
Welcome to a special BONUS episode of Storyteller with our lovely guest host- DES!!!!❤️🎄"He sees you when you're sleeping..." and in some cultures, he's bringing a birch rod and a sack to kidnap you. ⛓️👹This episode, St...
•
Episode 15
•
45:46
Ronald Gene Simmon's Christmas Killing Spree
The darkest secret kept for the holidays...In December 1987, Ronald Gene Simmons, a decorated former U.S. military serviceman, enacted the deadliest case of familicide in American history—a horrific rampage spanning a week in rural Arkan...
•
Episode 14
•
49:01
Santa's Got a Gun-The Santa Claus Bank Robbery
Christmas in Texas was supposed to be peaceful in 1927… until Santa walked into a bank and everything went to hell. What started as a harmless holiday costume turned into gunfire, chaos, and the biggest manhunt the state had ever seen.In...
•
Episode 13
•
41:51
Fox Hollow Farm: The Serial Killer No One Talks About
He killed more men than Dahmer or Gacy — yet most people have never heard his name.In this episode, we uncover the chilling true story of Herb Baumeister, the seemingly ordinary Indiana businessman, husband, and father whos...
•
Episode 12
•
1:56:46
Keep Sweet, Obey, Escape(Part Three): The Fall of Warren Jeffs
In the final chapter of our FLDS deep-dive, we uncover what happened after Warren Jeffs seized power — the moment faith turned into fear, and a community became a controlled kingdom of silence. We break down the suffocating rules, the destructi...
•
Episode 11
•
1:21:40
Keep Sweet, Obey, Escape(Part Two): The Making of Warren Jeffs
Part Two is Here!! The Making of Warren Jeffs Content warning: discussion of abuse, child abuse, and spiritual coercion.Before he became the self-proclaimed Prophet of the FLDS and one of America’s most notorious cult l...
•
Episode 10
•
1:17:51
Keep Sweet, Obey, Escape(Part One): The FLDS Origins
Imagine being born into a dynasty where faith is law, obedience is survival, and a man’s word determines your destiny. In this episode, we follow the gripping true story of Carolyn Jessop, a sixth-generation member of the FLDS who defied...
•
Episode 9
•
45:32
The Rocky Top Murders
Beneath Gatlinburg’s neon lights, pancake houses, and souvenir shops lies a chilling true story that most visitors will never hear.In 1986, a confession letter left in a phone booth in Maggie Valley unraveled one of Tennessee’s most brut...
•
Episode 8
•
51:02
✨BONUS EPISODE✨ Red Eyes: The Mad Man of Camp Manatoc
Grab your marshmallows and settle in by the fire—because this week on Storyteller, we’re taking you deep into the haunted woods of Ohio to uncover one of Appalachia’s creepiest legends: Red Eyes, The Mad Man of Camp Manatoc.But this epis...
•
Episode 7
•
27:45
Sarah Henry- The Woman in the Cellar
In the latest installment of our Spooky Season series, we’re headed to southwest Virginia, once again recording from the deck...at night...in rural Appalachia—to dig into the story behind America’s loudest founding father… and his darkest secre...
•
Episode 6
•
31:08